Churches in our Presbytery
Whitewater Valley Presbytery is the regional governing body for 48 churches and 4 new worshiping communities in central and eastern Indiana.
Our Annual
Anderson
First Presbyterian
230 W. 9th Street
Anderson, IN 46016
765-642-0219
www.1stpresanderson.org
1stpres@1stpresanderson.org
Vacant, Pastor
William Beeler, Clerk
Daniel Davisson, Treasurer
Avon
White Lick Presbyterian
2530 N 600 E
Avon, IN 46123-9272
317-852-2840
www.whitelickpcusa.org
wlpres@whitelickpcusa.org
​
Vancant, Pastor
Annetta Davis, Clerk
Trina Corbett, Treasurer
Bluffton
First Presbyterian
215 E Dustman
Bluffton, IN 46714-1204
260-824-0767
www.firstpcbluffton.org
firstpres@adamswells.org
​
Terry Epling, Pastor
Ira Zadylak, Clerk
Sherry Hiday, Treasurer
Boggstown
First Presbyterian
2488 North Sand Creek Road
Boggstown, IN 46110
317-835-2330
boggstownpresbyterian@gmail.com
​
Roger McDaniel, Temporary Supply Pastor
Megan Hart, Clerk
Chris Eck, Treasurer
Brookville
Mount Carmel Presbyterian
4011 St Rd 252
Brookville, IN 47012-9454
Andrew Zinsmeister, Pastor
Linda Fox, Clerk
Linda Fox, Treasurer
Clayton
Clayton Presbyterian
P.O. Box 157
4887 Pennsylvania Ave
Clayton, IN 46118-0157
317-539-2306
www.claytonpresby.org
pastor@claytonpresb.org
​
Lucia Hutchinson, Temporary Supply Pastor
Dawn West, Clerk
Kenneth Edmondson, Treasurer
Connersville
First Presbyterian
700 Central Ave.
Connersville, IN 47331
765-825-4189
www.connerpres.org
connerpres@frontier.com
​Vacant, Pastor
Carla Beard, Clerk
Linda Ward, Treasurer
Edinburg
Edinburgh Presbyterian
306 E Main Cross St
Edinburgh, IN 46124
812-526-5247
Vacant, Pastor
Lois Steele, Clerk
Robert Ackerman, Treasurer
Fishers
New Hope Presbyterian
12550 Brooks School Rd
Fishers, IN 46037
317-842-5171
newhopefishers.org
office@newhopefishers.org
​
Greg Steible, Pastor
Dave Pacenka, Clerk
Heather Ciscell, Treasurer
Fort Wayne
First Presbyterian
300 West Wayne Street
Fort Wayne, IN 46802
260-426-7421
firstpresfortwayne.org
​
Anne Epling, Pastor
Youngsoo An, Associate Pastor
Carrie Winebrenner, Associate Pastor
Denise Davis, Clerk
Andres Kopec, Treasurer
Fort Wayne
Grace Presbyterian
1811 Fairhill Rd
Fort Wayne, IN 46808
260-426-4712
www.gpcfw.org
graceoffice@gpcfw.org
​
Sandy Garcia, Pastor
John Current, Clerk
JoAnn Getts, Treasurer
Fort Wayne
United Faith Presbyterian
1616 W Main St
Fort Wayne, IN 46808
260-424-5610
Website
ufpc4197@frontier.com
Lyle Ewing, Temporary Supply Pastor
Kevin Boyd, Temporary Supply Pastor
Peg Kelley, Clerk
Bonnie Moore, Treasurer
Franklin
First Presbyterian
100 E Madison St
Franklin, IN 46131
317-736-6952
ffpc.us
fpcfranklinin@gmail.com
​
Vacant, Pastor
Gregg Cantwell, Clerk
Kathy Andrews, Treasurer
Greensburg
First Presbyterian
202 N Franklin
Greensburg, IN 47240
812-663-2197
www.fpcgburg.orgf
pcgburg@etczone.com
​
Marena Vittorio Schindler Co-Pastor
Garrett Vittorio Schindler Co-Pastor
Catherine Lincourt, Clerk
Roy Simpson, Treasurer
Greensburg
Kingston Presbyterian
4783 E Co Rd 280 N
Greensburg, IN 47240
Website
A. J. Mildenberg, Bridge Pastor
Ed Parker, Clerk
Bart Metz, Treasurer
Greensburg
Springhill Presbyterian
3954 E Co Rd 640 N
Greensburg, IN 47240
Website
​
A. J. Mildenberg, Bridge Pastor
Pam Blasdel, Clerk
Daryl Tressler, Treasurer
Greenwood
Greenwood Presbyterian
102 W Main St
Greenwood, IN 46142
317-881-1259
greenwoodpres.org
charlotte@greenwoodpc.org
​
Peter Zinn, Pastor
Jan Mernone, Clerk
Lauren Underwood, Treasurer
Hartford City
First Presbyterian
117 W Franklin
Hartford City, IN 47348
765-348-1431
Website
firstpreshc@sbcglobal.net
​
Wes Rediger, Interim Pastor
Dan Borgenheimer, Clerk
Kathy Kellogg, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Fairview Presbyterian
4609 N Capitol
Indianapolis, IN 46208
317-251-2245
www.fairviewpresbyterian.org
youbelong@fairviewpresbyterian.org
​
Shawn Coons, Pastor
Tia Jah Wynne-Ayers, Clerk
Brad Prather, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Faith Presbyterian
8170 Hague Road
Indianapolis, IN 46256
317-849-1930
www.indianapolisfaith.org
​
Charlotte Lohrenz, Pastor/Head of Staff
Ann Lowell, Clerk​
​
​
Indianapolis
First Meridian Heights Presbyterian
4701 Central Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46205
317-283-1305
www.fmhpc.org
office@fmhpc.org
​
Kimberly Olson, Pastor
Phil Votaw, Clerk
Brooke Kile, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Irvington Presbyterian
55 Johnson Ave.
Indianapolis, IN 46219
317-356-7225
www.irvpresby.org
lchapman@irvpresby.org
​
Jonathan Reinink, Pastor
T.J. Hengst, Clerk
James Young, Treasurer
Indianapolis
John Knox Presbyterian
3000 N High School Rd
Indianapolis, IN 46224
317-291-0308
www.johnknox.org
office@johnknox.org
​
Kelly Jepsen, Pastor
Pam Herman, Clerk
Cindy Hiday, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Korean Presbyterian
1020 E 101st St
Indianapolis, IN 46280
317-844-6484
www.kpci.org
kpci@kpci.org
​
David Pak, Pastor
Jin Hyuck Yoon, Clerk
Jin Hyuck Yoon, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Northminster Presbyterian
1660 Kessler Blvd E Dr
Indianapolis, IN 46220
317-251-9489
www.northminster-indy.org
office@northminster-indy.org
​
Brian Shivers, Pastor
Karen Herbst-Kim, Associate Pastor
Cheryl Plunkett, Clerk
Rob Rothrock, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Orchard Park Presbyterian
1605 E 106th St
Indianapolis, IN 46280
317-844-1107
www.orchardpark.org
oppc@orchardpark.org
​
Gracie Payne, Pastor
Terrence Brookie, Clerk
Tom Kapostasy, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Second Presbyterian
7700 N Meridian St
Indianapolis, IN 46260
317-253-6461
www.secondchurch.org
2church@secondchurch.org
​
Christopher Henry, Senior Pastor
Karen Lang, Executive Pastor
Michael Samson, Associate Pastor
Audrey Thorne, Associate Pastor
Madison VanVeelen, Associate Pastor
Tom Markey, Associate Pastor
Caroline Eader, Lake Fellow
Zach Rivers, Lake Fellow
Cathie Reese, Clerk
John Yeo, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Southminster Presbyterian
9950 Southeastern
Indianapolis, IN 46239
317-862-6612
www.southminsterindy.com
office@southminster-pcusa.org
Molly DeWitt, Pastor
Lisa Schnepp, Clerk
Chris Yoke, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Tabernacle Presbyterian
418 E 34th St
Indianapolis, IN 46205
317-923-5458
www.tabpres.org
frontdesk@tabpres.org
​
Clark Cowden, Interim Pastor
Steve Smith, Temporary Associate Pastor
Bruce McDonald, Clerk
Dave King, Treasurer
Indianapolis
Witherspoon Presbyterian
3535 W. Kessler Blvd. North Drive
Indianapolis, IN 46222
317-251-2297
www.wpcindy.org
wpcweb2020@gmail.com
​
Winterbourne Harrison-Jones, Pastor
Nikki Graham, Clerk
Dr. Robert Stokes, Treasurer
Jonesboro
First Presbyterian of Grant County
601 S Main St
Jonesboro, IN 46938
765-674-4462
www.firstpresgrantcounty.com
firstpres601@gmail.com
Dan Bowell, CRE
Richard Wade, Clerk
David Shelley, Treasurer
Knightstown
Bethel Presbyterian
112 S Franklin
Knightstown, IN 46148
813-898-3954
Website
Sam Frost, CRE
Mary Jo Purtee, Clerk
Kim Frost, Treasurer
Lewisville
First Presbyterian
PO Box 305
Lewisville, IN 47352
765-987-8888
Website
Vacant, Pastor
Joyce Winchester, Clerk
David Sweet, Treasurer
McCordsville
Christ Presbyterian
7879 N 700 W
McCordsville, IN 46056
317-335-7600
www.christpresby.org
59948@christpresby.org
​
Wally Wilson, Stated Supply Pastor
William Schofield, Clerk
William Schofield, Treasurer
Muncie
First Presbyterian
1400 W Riverside Ave
Muncie, IN 47303
765-289-4431
www.firstpresmuncie.org
info@firstpresmuncie.org
​
Daren Hofmann, Pastor
Myungku Lee, Associate Pastor
Aileen Howard, Clerk
Bill McCune, Treasurer
Muncie
Saint Andrew Presbyterian
2700 W Moore Rd
Muncie, IN 47304
765-282-6466
saintandrewmuncie.com
saintandrew@comcast.net
Ramona Dale, Pastor
Carma Shawger, Clerk
Jacqueline Nelson, Treasurer
New Castle
First Presbyterian
1202 Church St
New Castle, IN 47362
765-529-3703
www.firstpresbyteriannc.org
office.1stpresbyterian@gmail.com
​
Katherine Rieder, Interim Pastor
Jim Millikan, Clerk
Jan Filipek, Treasurer
Noblesville
First Presbyterian
1207 Conner St
Noblesville, IN 46060
317-773-2383
www.fpc-noblesville.org
fpc-noblesville@ori.net
​
Ken Locke, Interim Pastor
Karen McCord, Clerk
Mark Wisely, Treasurer
Portland
First Presbyterian
402 N Ship St
Portland, IN 47371
260-726-8462
www.firstpcportland.org
office@firstpcportland.org
Rex Espiritu, Pastor
Jennifer Rupe, Clerk
Larry Hiatt, Treasurer
Richmond
First Presbyterian
100 N 10th St
Richmond, IN 47374
765-966-2234
www.firstpresbyterianrichmond.org
fpcrichmond100@gmail.com
Dave Daniel, Bridge Pastor
Diane Whitehead, Clerk
Larry Coblentz, Treasurer
Rushville
First Presbyterian
226 N Morgan St
Rushville, IN 46173
765-932-2175
Website
firstpresrush@gmail.com
Roy Peters, Temporary Supply
Carol Lempke, Clerk
Cindy Taff, Treasurer
Rushville
Trinity Presbyterian
631 N Harrison
Rushville, IN 46173
765-932-2198
Website
trinitypresrushville@gmail.com
​
John Wall, Commissioned Ruling Elder
Anny Lacy, Clerk
Larry Scott, Treasurer
Shelbyville
First Presbyterian
124 W Broadway
Shelbyville, IN 46176
317-398-8224
www.fpcshelbyville.org
info@fpcshelbyville.org
​
Gretchen Schneider, Covenant Pastor
Sarah Smith, Clerk
Glenn Hobbs, Treasurer
Tipton
First Presbyterian
200 W Jefferson
Tipton, IN 46072
765-675-4599
Website
presbych@tiptontel.com
​
Phil Votaw, Commissioned Ruling Elder
Mary Chittum, Clerk
Linda Joins, Treasurer
Westfield
Crossroads Presbyterian
19201 Grassy Branch Rd
Westfield, IN 46074
317-896-7000
www.crcw.org
crchurchwestfield@gmail.com
​
Eric Lohe, Pastor
Jeremy Thornberry, Clerk
Tammy Havard, Treasurer
Winchester
First Presbyterian
201 Franklin St
Winchester, IN 47394
765-584-5141
WinchesterFPC.org
Email
Vacant, Pastor
Suzanne Fogleman, Clerk
Suzanne Fogleman, Treasurer
Zionsville
Zionsville Presbyterian
4775 W 116th St
Zionsville, IN 46077
317-873-6503
www.zpc.org
zpc@zpc.org
​
Jerry Deck, Pastor
Scott Shelton, Associate Pastor
Lynn Thomas, Clerk
Mar, Treasurer